Only a sith deals in absolutes meaning

The simple fact is that vader was greatly confused, and was little more than a puppet to Sidious' genius. The line itself is an absolute.

Duel on Mustafar

So poor script is the only real explanation. Or maybe that was intended irony. Obiwan can be kinda a dick. It a ridiculous line like you need to be a Sith to be a fanatic in the Star Wars mitho. In other words the Jedis are more doubtful and can actually take into accountability their flaws, where as the sith are over confident and way too proud for their power. Basically in lamest terms obi was saying "shit.. Fuck dude you really are a sith".


  • mortels coupon code;
  • Bevor Sie fortfahren...!
  • coupons rabais vagisil.

Yeah, Lucas was trying to ham-fistedly compare Darth Vader to George W Bush when he stated "Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists. But yeah, it always bothered me even back in Return of the Jedi that the first thing Luke thinks of after Yoda confirms who Vader is, is "I cant kill my own father. Of course, Yoda didnt say he had to kill Vader, just "confront" him. Which Luke did. And everything turned out better than expected. It also completely contradicts when yoda says "do or do not, there is no try" in ESB.

Cake Day. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Can someone explain "Only a Sith deals in absolutes. If you aren't Sith? You're weak and deserve to die. Continue this thread. It is paralleled, when Obi-wan, telling Anakin "only a Sith deals in absolutes" reveals himself as a hypocrite, likely unknowingly. I hear this a lot, and have even made fun of it myself.

#PHILOSOPHICALPILLS: Jedi and Sith, Epicureanism and Stoicism in the Star Wars universe

BUT, I sometimes think folks aren't slowing down enough to consider what was actually said:. First, what was NOT said. Once you make unilateral proposals, you aren't negotiating, you aren't even really "dealing" at all. Third, think of the context. Anakin is saying things like you're either with him or against him.

Not, "let me hear what you think" or "give me your perspective on this matter. It's not a contradiction to say Only a Sith deals in absolutes. Making an absolute statement such as "There are no absolutes" would, however, be a contradiction. I think that the word being overlooked here is "deals". It is one thing to make an absolute statement. It is another to make one that refers to a fight. The words "deals in" refers to how Anakin thought he had to fight Obi-wan. It was a battle deal.

Rising Young Minds

The only reason Obi-wan fought Anakin was because Anakin was attacking. It makes sense now because Obi-wan was not making any absolute statement that was dealing in combat. Of course, there are bound to be mistakes all throughout the Star Wars dialogue. We like to try to make sense of things, but in reality the things people say on Earth are often filled with error.

People make mistakes, and this shines through even in movies. After all, movies are made by people. It's a fairly common fallacy. Who here hasn't heard "Nothing is black and white. Many people are unaware of the inherent inconsistency of the statement.

Duel on Mustafar

While many things are to some extent gray areas, a statement ruling out absolutes is itself absolute! The Sith often make the naive mistake of simplifying a situation into black-and-white more than is reasonable. You're making a mistake consistent with the ideologies of our enemies. Can't you see how you've been fooled into working for the other side? Importantly, that line was from the RotS. It's a well-accepted part of the SW universe that one of the reasons that the original trilogy was better was that Lucas wasn't so famous that you couldn't talk him out of his sillier ideas.


  • Watch Next.
  • o las vegas coupons;
  • michaels coupon stockton ca?
  • "Only a Sith deals in absolutes"..? - Popular Media - Catholic Answers Forums.

By the time the prequel trilogy rolled around, he was much too big a person to say no to. In my opinion Obi-Wan used that line when he finally realized, that he can't talk down Anakin back to jedi way. To me it was more like a quote, as if Obi-Wan quoted some ancient statement as last hope to get understanding of the situation into Anakin's head. I mean like we on Earth sometime use "The die has been cast" or similar statements and everyone in room knows what it means because its part of our history, as that statement could be part of history of the Jedi order.

But this is just speculation. I was struck by this line as well when I first heard it in the movie, as not very many lines of that caliber as in thought-provoking appear in the "newer" movies. This is a line written in the film to show how far Anakin had really gone. Obi-wan was really the only Jedi at the end who still supported Anakin, and still listened to him when he was angry about being rejected from the title of Jedi Master.

The council had for the most part distanced themselves from him. If you think about it, the Sith are portrayed for the most part as cold-blooded, robotic beings, fueled only by their desire for power, power and more power. The line referring to Anakin's new vision of everything as black and white meant he was losing touch with his human feelings and therefore reality.

Cold hard logic: This is further evidenced in the fight between the two Jedi, Obi-wan and Anakin where Obi-wan states:. At which point he, meaning Anakin, loses many of his appendages. Darth Vader had become so heartless that he did not even calculate the danger of his body being injured by attacking at point. Yes it makes Obi-Wan a sith, that is why they had to fight. There can only be two sith at a time, and since Palpatine was on another planet, the only solution was to strike Anakin down to restore balance to the force.

A good Jedi like Obi-Wan is able to understand the importance of keeping the force in balance, even if it means embracing elements of the dark side while retaining his sense of justice, and without losing his perception of good and evil. Thank you for your interest in this question.

Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site the association bonus does not count. Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead? Home Questions Tags Users Unanswered. If only the Sith deal in absolutes, why does Obi-Wan say it that way? Ask Question.

What is the Gray Force in Star Wars? - What Gray Force Means in Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Obviously, Obi-Wan is a secret Sith. Obi-Wan was the most awesome of the Sith! Wouldn't Yoda's "Do or do not, there is no try" be an absolute statement?


  • “Only a Sith Deals in Absolutes” (Don’t Believe It);
  • Can someone explain "Only a Sith deals in absolutes."?.
  • hotel deals near portland maine.
  • News + Blog Categories;

Waite Jul 16 '13 at 9: This is the same kind of spurious circular logic that a lot of right-wingers use when they say "Your intolerance of my intolerance shows that your message of tolerance is hypocritical! One can imagine the following, more elegant exchange: Aaron Hall 1 9. Chris B.

Is Obi-Wan a Hypocrite?

Behrens Chris B.